Explain the meaning of the following quotations and discuss their contemporary relevance. "Men must have corrupted nature a little, for they were not born wolves, and they have become wolves." (Answer in 150 words) 10 Marks
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The essence of this quote is that the foundational nature, the essence of men, is that of goodness.
Meaning of quote 1. Nature, the essence of humanity, is goodness/purity of all people at birth. 2. The quote seems to say that the ill-doings of men have corrupted the natural process of growth of men. → Now, due to corruption of the natural process of growth, when people grow up they are a little like "wolves", i.e., a little "not good". 3. This refers to the contemporary relevance: 1. Growing tendency for violence/abuse on social media. (eg) echo chambers. 2. Criminalisation of politics, globally. 3. Abuse of environment. (eg) mining waste, misuse of natural resources, deforestation, etc. 4. Rise of corruption in bureaucracy. 5. Rise in economic offences such as cyber theft. (eg) increased 3x in 2 years according to NCRB data. 6. Violence against women/SC/ST community. (eg) similarly rising according to NCRB. 7. Global conflicts. (eg) Russia-Ukraine crisis.
Counter-view 1. The inherent character of man is "goodness". 2. It is inside of each one of us, just as divinity is. 3. There are enough instances of the same across all spheres of life. (eg) Padma Shri Tulsi Gowda dedicating her whole life to environment.
The only thing is, now we are focussing more on the "wolves".
Thus, I disagree with the given quote.