Topper Copies

How has the Anti-Defection Law impacted the relationship between political parties and individual legislators in India? In light of the recent incidents also discuss the unintended consequences it has on the functioning of democracy in India.

Ruhani, AIR 5, 2023

Anti-defection law, 1985 is a Constitutional Amendment act inserted in the tenth schedule of the Constitution.

It was enacted to prevent political corruption through defection of individuals from one party to another.

Impact of this law on the relationship between political parties and legislators -> Hamper Inner party democracy:- Legislators cannot dissent or disagree with their party on many important national issues. -> Permits wholesale mergers but prevents retail mergers -> Allurement through promise of position of ministership make legislators to leave their party and join another. -> Instability in the relationship

Unintended consequences on democracy -> Dissent stifled:- New opinions or differences are not heard. MPs cannot vote their conscience, they cannot defy whip. -> Thus, MPs work for their party and not for the people of their constituency. -> This weakens representative democracy -> Downfall of governments, eg. in Maharashtra -> Instability in policy making -> Political corruption.

Way forward -> Speaker should exercise non-partisan role while announcing disqualification for defection. -> The law should apply to pre-poll alliances.

Thus, anti-defection law needs to be rethought and re-designed.