"To achieve a good life, duty is not sufficient; one needs to develop one's sympathetic feelings for others, and neither duty alone nor good will alone are sufficient to be moral." Do you agree with the above statement? Justify your position. (Answer in 150 words)
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
No, I do not agree with the above statement, as duty involves sympathetic feelings.
Duty alone is sufficient, as:
1. If a person does his duty in letter and spirit, sympathy, empathy and compassion are part of that duty. (eg) they are foundational values for civil services, as per the 2nd ARC. 2. Thus, it is not possible to do duty as a civil servant, without sympathy. If a civil servant is empathetic, his duty will come naturally to him; if he/she is not, he will just do it as a job. (ie) duty encompasses empathy. 3. (eg) Suppose a civil servant is asked to clear illegal encroachment from streets:
(as ruled by SC in the Rajesh Yadav case) (thus: duty encompasses compassion to aid others) 4. Similarly, for a police officer, as PM Modi has said, the mantra must be SMART, where S stands for sensitivity. 5. Likewise, for tax officials, the mantra must be RAPID, where P stands for probity. Probity is not possible in a tax jurisdiction where citizens don't feel vertical or horizontal fairness, or have low tax morale.
Thus, duty alone is sufficient, as the Gita also says.