Public service takes place in a bureaucratic structure with clear lines of authority, value standardization, and accountability mechanisms. Working within such a structure, what do you think are the influences that impact the public servant's ethical decision-making? (Answer in 150 words)
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
A public servant's ethical decision-making is impacted by internal and external factors, and how they interact with the organisation and society.
They are:
(I) Individual cognitive 1. Influences by family, school, etc. 2. Personal morals and biases - (eg) cultural approach: some people may prefer to learn the local language, others may prefer to put more effort into the technical aspects of work. - (eg) Divya Devarajan (IAS) learnt the Gond language.
(II) Value standardisation - (eg) Code of Ethics - by 2nd ARC - (eg) similarly, Office of Government Ethics in USA - to standardize
(III) Organisational normative 1. Work culture. - (eg) internal office communication protocols - (eg) in my job, my Manager always had an open office and encouraged people to walk in at any time.
(IV) Lines of authority - (eg) in armed forces.
(V) Societal - legal 1. Determine acceptance of certain practices. - (eg) acceptability of corruption in Indian society earlier → corrupt bureaucrats were not condemned → changed after the IAC movement.
(VI) Accountability mechanisms - (eg) Prevention of Corruption Act, 1988. - (eg) RTI Act - requires voluntary disclosure.
Thus, there are a variety of factors. A good civil servant is aware of all of these and their utility.