Topper Copies

Discuss the implications of legalising MSP. What are the challenges involved, and what measures can improve its effectiveness?

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

The GoI announces MSP upon the recommendations of the CCAP as a price stabilisation measure, but during the recent farmer protests there have been demands to provide MSP as a legal entitlement.

MSP Legalisation & price shocks 1. legal MSP would ensure right to a minimum level of price for crops 2. It would ensure both private & public procurement is done at a fixed minimum rate 3. it would prevent distress selling by farmers when prices fall due to cobweb phenomenon in agriculture 4. ensure certainty of income to farmers even during periods of surplus produce

Challenges with legal MSP 1. MSP procurement is limited to states like PB, HR, west UP eg Shantakumar committee -> only 6% agricultural households sell produce at MSP 2. there are only 23 crops under MSP which comprise of only 20% of the total agricultural produce of India 3. MSP procurement is also biased in favour of paddy and wheat. Farmers of vegetables, fruits, pulses, oilseeds etc may not benefit 4. private players may not purchase crops at MSP greater than market price 5. legal procurement of MSP has a huge fiscal cost eg studies -> 9Lcr 6. legal MSP may also violate WTO norms under amber box 7. also storage of forward linkages like storage, warehouse, mandis, roads etc

Measures for effectiveness 1. ensure bread based procurement of all crops under MSP focusing on pulses oilseeds and millets to ensure self sufficiency and nutritional security 2. Shanta Kumar committee suggests FCI should focus on procurement in those areas where it is weaker 3. Prevent malpractices by Arhatiyas in mandis 4. increase awareness regarding e-NAM to ensure all agri HH can sell produce at MSP

way forward: A price differential payment system can also be explored to directly pay farmers the difference between MSP and market price.

Legalisation of MSP is a complex policy matter any progress in this regard should be via a participatory & inclusive dialogue with all key stakeholders.