Compare the Gandhian and revolutionary streams of the Indian freedom movement in the 1920s-1930s, bringing out their similarities, differences and mutual influence.
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
The disillusionment with Gandhian politics and influence from the Russian revolution led to the development of the Revolutionary movements in 1920s-1930s.
Similarities
1. Both were anti colonialism and reflected deep patriotic sentiments. 2. Both wanted to weed out social evils like casteism, violence against women, communalism from the Indian society.
[a sketch of India marking revolutionary activities: Delhi assembly bombing, Kakori train robbery, Chittagong armoury raid]
3. Both wanted to improve upon the colonial economic structure. (eg) Gandhiji → cottage industries, Bhagat Singh → modernisation.
Differences
| Revolutionaries | Gandhi | |---|---| | Did not shy away from using violence (eg) Bombing in central legislative assembly | Was anti violence and preached ahimsa (eg) Champaran satyagraha | | They believed in extreme communism & socialism | Believed in gram swarajya & stateless society | | Was against negotiations with government | Negotiated with government to realise goals (eg) Gandhi-Irwin pact | | Relied on quixotic individual heroism | Relied on collective strength of masses | | Did not enjoy wide popularity | Enjoyed massive popularity | | Movements were short lived and easily suppressed | Movements were long and tough to suppress |
Influence on one another
1. Though Gandhiji was against use of violence he too called for "do-or die" during the Quit India Movement. 2. Though revolutionaries relied on violence their intent was never to hurt or cause casualties, they only wanted to "make the deaf hear" reflecting foundational value of ahimsa.
Both Revolutionaries & Gandhiji had a role to play in our freedom struggle, & our fundamental duties urge us to respect these noble ideas of the freedom struggle.