Compare the ancient centres of higher education, Nalanda and Taxila, with modern universities, and discuss the lessons contemporary higher education can learn from them.
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Recently the PM Modi inaugurated the campus of Nalanda University highlighting the rich history of higher education in India.
Nalanda and Taxila were centres of higher education during ancient Indian history.
[a map of India marking Taxila and Nalanda, connected by the Uttara Patha and the Silk route]
Nalanda & Taxila vs Modern University
| | Nalanda & Taxila | Modern University | |---|---|---| | Pedagogy | oral tradition, focus on observational learning | written tradition, focus on getting grades & placements | | Subjects taught | philosophy, astrology, medicine, buddhism | more scientific and less spiritual subjects | | Students | from across the world joined | mostly Indian students | | Finance | independent (eg) Nalanda had access to revenue of 100 villages | depend on central & state grants | | Academic freedom | teachers were free to experiment with their courses | teachers are bound by standardised curriculum |
Lessons to be learnt from ancient universities
1. Increasing critical discourse regarding academic debates and enhance academic freedom (eg) recent case of Ashoka university controversy. 2. Ensure financial independence of universities. 3. Strive to become international centres of academic excellence attracting best global minds and decreasing brain drains. 4. Reorienting pedagogy to focus on moral values and spiritual discourses. 5. Groom teachers to be the best in their fields (eg) Panini, Nagarjuna are teachers at Taxila & Nalanda. 6. Improve campus atmosphere to decrease instances of ragging, suicides etc.
We have a lot to learn from our past. The NEP 2020 paves way for realising these goals through strategies like Glue front scheme and academic bank of credit.