Discuss the arguments for and against the implementation of a Uniform Civil Code in India in the context of Uttarakhand's recent legislation.
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Recently the Uttarakhand has brought in its own UCC. The UCC is a set of uniform civil laws concerning marriage, divorce, adoption etc contained in article 44, Part IV of the constitution.
UCC contradicts religious pluralism & cultural differences.
Arguments for 1. Article 25 allows for freedom of religion to all citizens. 2. UCC ignores cultural diversity in India. (eg) Khasi tribe → matrilinear, mainland tribes → patrilinear. 3. It may be against certain religious practices. (eg) Islam allows polygamy but UCC bans polygamy. 4. It contradicts art 29 & 30 (cultural rights).
Arguments against 1. Religious and cultural rights in Part III are not absolute and subject to reasonable restrictions. 2. Religious practices and Civil laws often lack progressiveness which breeds discrimination especially against women. (eg) Parsi women loose their inheritance if they marry outside the community. 3. "Uniform" in UCC does not mean common for all, there is scope to accommodate the diversity in a uniform code which is progressive.
UCC does not contradict religious & cultural diversity but enables them by reforming civil laws, however there is a need to build consensus across communities to address their concerns.