Topper Copies

Discuss the necessity of extending the BSF's jurisdiction along India's borders. What issues does this raise?

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

The BSF is a CAPF entrusted with the responsibility of border management along the Pakistan & Bangladesh border. Recently the GoI extended its jurisdiction to up to 50km from the border in some states

Necessity 1. to maintain territorial integrity 2. to deter issues of smuggling, human trafficking and other organized crimes like drug smuggling etc 3. to deal with the issue of increasing use of drones 4. to deter issue of terrorism eg attacks in Jammu recently 5. to keep check on illegal migrants 6. maintain peace & stability in border districts and facilitate their development

Issues 1. increased tussle between centre and states eg PB v/s GoI, WB v/s GoI 2. undermines federalism 3. conflicts between state police & BSF 4. issues of human right violations by BSF 5. states like PB argue extended jurisdiction covers more than half of the total districts decreasing state's role in their administration

India is surrounded by hostile neighbours, but there is a need to balance both national security and federalism especially in border states.