Topper Copies

Priya, an IAS officer serving as the Municipal Commissioner of ABC City, is faced with a challenging ethical dilemma. The state government has approved a Smart City project, which includes the construction of a multi-lane expressway and modern commercial complexes. The project aims to boost economic activity, enhance urban mobility, and attract investment, positioning ABC as a model for sustainable urban development. However, the proposed expressway passes through the old city area, which is home to centuries-old heritage buildings, temples, and a community of artisans who rely on tourism and handicrafts for their livelihood. Experts warn that the construction will lead to the demolition of historic structures and the displacement of traditional craftsmen, thereby threatening the city's cultural identity. Heritage conservationists and local communities are strongly opposing the project, advocating for alternative routes or modifications to preserve the old city's heritage. Conversely, business groups, real estate developers, and political leaders argue that urban development is essential for progress and that heritage concerns should not obstruct modernization. Priya must navigate these conflicting interests, ensuring that the government's urban development agenda is implemented while also safeguarding the city's rich cultural heritage and the livelihoods of vulnerable communities. (a) Identify the key stakeholders involved in the case and analyze their respective interests. (b) Discuss the ethical dilemmas faced by Priya in balancing urban development, heritage conservation, and the rights of local communities.

Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025

(a) Interests of stakeholders

- Community - Culture preservation - Traditional livelihoods - Business groups -> Economic growth - Political leaders -> growth, promise & progress

(b) Ethical dilemmas faced by Priya

- Growth vs Heritage - Sustainability

Priya's actions must follow Article 51 A(f) and pursue cultural heritage