Topper Copies

A devastating flood has struck regions of a flood-prone state, leading to widespread humanitarian distress. Amid ongoing rescue operations, social media is flooded with claims that relief efforts are being deliberately delayed for certain communities. These posts go viral, fueling communal tensions and eroding public trust in disaster response agencies. Ishita, a senior officer in the State Information Department, conducts an investigation and finds that most of these claims are either unsubstantiated or manipulated. However, she faces mounting pressure from different stakeholders. Political leaders seize the social media outrage as an opportunity to criticize the ruling party, calling for a judicial inquiry. Activists argue that removing or countering these posts could be seen as a violation of free speech. Further complicating the matter, a high-ranking government official instructs Ishita to refrain from taking action, fearing that any intervention might be perceived as an attempt to suppress dissent. Ishita is deeply concerned that unchecked misinformation could escalate communal tensions and undermine the credibility of the administration. However, intervening too aggressively could trigger accusations of censorship and political bias, placing her in a difficult ethical position. (a) Identify the ethical dilemmas faced by Ishita in handling the misinformation crisis. (b) What should be Ishita's course of action in balancing freedom of speech, public order, and government directives? Justify your response. (c) What steps can be taken to prevent misinformation during natural disasters?

Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025

"In times of crises, truth is the first casualty"

This case presents a situation wherein misinformation is furthering the damage caused by a flood

(a) Ethical Dilemmas faced by Ishita

1. Spread of misinformation vs Right to free speech under Article 19 2. Balancing valid usage of social media with false news curbing 3. Censorship vs Public safety in times of crises 4. Moral imperative vs Institutional pressure - by high ranking officer. 5. Politicisation of a natural disaster

(b) Ishita's Course of Action should be

1. Setting up a task force to identify false posts 2. Holding discussions with social media companies - finding ways to identify false news. 3. In the meanwhile, issue a formal warning about misinformation 4. Proactively share reports of relief activities to eliminate scope of misinformation 5. Once task force identifies false posts with evidence - take down the false posts. 6. Issue an official document citing reasons for removal of them posts 7. Issue another notice re-iterating committment to free speech. 8. Explain your actions to seniors with proper documentation & evidences

(c) Steps to prevent misinformation during natural disasters

1. Proactive disclosure of relief activities & action plans. 2. Engaging with civil society members to ensure that true information is propagated 3. Rebuilding communication infra damaged in disaster to resume news coverage. 4. Asking media houses to provide correct on-ground reports 5. Collaborate with social Media companies to identify false reports. 6. Use of technology like AI to identify forged videos

Such an approach will enable the triumph of truth even in times of crises.