Akshay, a junior officer in the Public Works Department (PWD), is part of the bid evaluation committee for a prestigious government contract to construct a large public hospital in a major city. During the evaluation, he observes that one of the leading bidders has strong connections to a senior politician's family. Despite the bidder's history of substandard construction work and project delays, several committee members appear to favor this bidder. Upon reviewing internal documents, Akshay uncovers evidence suggesting that the bidder's technical credentials have been exaggerated in the evaluation reports. Simultaneously, a more qualified construction company, with a smaller scale but a better track record, has been overlooked. Akshay is concerned that awarding the contract to the politically connected bidder would endanger public safety and lead to wasteful expenditure of taxpayer money. Despite his ethical concerns, Akshay fears that raising the issue may lead to retaliation from senior officials, potentially jeopardizing his career and standing within the department. He is thus caught in a moral conflict between his duty to the public and personal job security. (a) Identify and analyze the ethical issues involved in the case. (b) Discuss the possible courses of action available to Akshay. What would be the most ethical and appropriate course of action in this situation? Justify your response.
Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025
This case presents the issue of Nepotism & Favouritism while depicting a conflict between personal & professional interests for Akshay
(a) Ethical issues involved in the given case
1. Nepotism and Favouritism in awarding the contract 2. Nexus between builders & politician - undue influence on governance 3. Nexus between evaluation committee and Politician 4. Passive Complicity of committee members 5. Conflict of interest for Akshay between personal & professional progress 6. Violation of the principle of Non-Malfeasance - endangering public lives. 7. Wasteful expenditure of taxpayer's money - non propreity
(b) Options Available to Akshay
1. Ignoring his findings
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Prevents misallocation of public funds | Delays the entire project | | Averts a crisis of conscience | May lead to retaliation at work |
2. Taking up the matter with seniors
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Based on discourse ethics | May alienate Akshay professionally | | Gives a chance to the committee for taking informed decision | Committee may already be compromised |
3. Filing a formal complaint
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Prevents unethical allocation | Professional consequences | | Prevents danger to public life | Delays development |
4. Whistleblowing
| Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Exposes decay of ethics | Against procedure if done directly | | Public awareness | May attract media trials |
Most ethical course of action
| Step Taken | Reason | |---|---| | Proper documentation of evidence | Due Dilligence | | Taking up the concerns with seniors | Amicable confrontation & deliberation | | Filing a formal complaint if step 2 has no effect | Procedural Ethics | | Whistleblowing | Primacy of truth |
Justification
This approach combines institutional procedures with moral correctness. It ensures the triumphs of truth without concerns for consequence to self (Socrates' Ideal Man). It leads to good of the general public