Singh Garh is a primarily rural district with minimal, relatively insignificant industrial activity, except for one consumer goods manufacturing plant, which was the primary source of employment. Development indicators such as health, literacy, etc., were much below the national average. Along with developmental issues, another grave concern was the slow rise in child marriages. Despite the legal sanctions, child marriage continued to rise unabated. Rashmi, a social work postgraduate who escaped an early marriage, started an NGO for rescuing and rehabilitating child marriage victims. In the last five years she saved a lot of young girls from becoming victims of child marriage. Her modus operandi was simple. She had developed a network of informants in villages who relayed information to her, and after verifying, Rashmi with help from local law enforcement personnel, prevented the marriage from happening. Rashmi did commendable work, but she made some enemies in the process. The local leaders resented her popularity with women and young girls in particular. To expand her activities, Rashmi contacted the management of the only industrial unit in the district. She successfully persuaded the company to contribute to her activities and the NGO. The company even gave her access to their facilities to conduct workshops for workers to raise awareness about the issue of child marriage. As she started her workshops and campaign on the company premises, the initial response was lukewarm and, at times, complete indifference. But she persevered. After a couple of months, one day, the company union members stopped her from entering the company and even threatened her with violence. Rashmi spoke with the management, who supported her and ensured her safety. The management issued a circular supporting Rashmi and her NGO. To management's surprise, after a week of the circular, the Union called for a flash strike and threatened to continue the work stoppage if the NGO activities continued. The workers believed that Rashmi's campaign was corrupting the women's minds and disrespecting their traditions. The company's management seeing the aggressive reaction sought to assuage the workers by stopping the NGO activities. Rashmi tried to persuade the management by highlighting their social responsibility to the community. But the management was curt in replying that every social problem is not their moral responsibility. Rashmi was disappointed with the management's decision and wondered how best to involve the company in her campaigns. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) What do you think Rashmi should do? Would it be a good idea for Rashmi to involve local administration? Suggest an implementable course of action. (c) Do you think companies should also accept responsibility for the social problems of the region where they operate? Why/why not? (d) What could be the reasons for such an aggressive reaction from the workers union? How do you think Rashmi should handle the workers union?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The given case is about the extent to which a communities' social issues are also that of a business, and about role of pressure groups in bringing about/stopping social change
(a) Issues 1. Child marriage 2. Resistance by local leaders (to Rashmi's activities) 3. Threat of violence by Trade Union 4. Strike by Trade Union. 5. Company dis-associating itself from NGO post the strike. 6. Company refusing to take any responsibility for community's social problem
(b) Approach for Rashmi 1. File police complaint against Union leaders for threatening her with violence (section 506 IPC, etc) 2. Complaint via Prohibition of Child Marriage Act, against Trade Union. 3. Work with local administration, as well as the company - to deregister such violent trade union. 4. Continuous attempts to re-engage the company management 5. Work with other civil society/companies in the region 6. Work with media -> to highlight her work -> create awareness -> highlight violence and threats, so that the blackmailers refrain from making such threats in future.
(c) Should companies accept responsibility for community problems Yes, companies should accept responsibility to some extent, for the social problems in their community:
1. Discharging their share of responsibility would also help them grow more sustainably => thus ensuring long term profitability 2. In this case, for example, it will endear company to females. -> potential female consumers -> potential female employees, in future 3. Similarly, environmental sustainability ensures long term survival 4. Concern for alcohol addiction ensures higher productivity of labour 5. Concern for health issues ensures healthy workforce 6. Also, if company helps community, community also helps the company in times of stress.
(d) Reasons for the union's aggressive reaction, and how to handle it Reasons for aggressive reaction from worker union: 1. Perceived threat to culture 2. Potential politicisation of issue. (trade unions are frequently associated with political parties) 3. Potential incitement by village elders 4. Lack of trust in any civil society/modern values 5. Poor past experience with modern ideas => leading to mistrust
Rashmi should take following steps to handle union: 1. Identify the reason for their strong reaction. 2. Use carrot-stick approach 3. For those elements who are violent/threatening her => work with police 4. For those members who are distrustful/who don't have awareness => create awareness -> highlight experiences/stories to win their trust -> educate them about benefits of late marriage 5. Use Aristotlean persuasion approach