Topper Copies

Mr. Sharma was the All India Sales Head of a pharmaceutical company with a turnover of 400 crores. The company's main markets were small towns and tier 2 cities. Further, the company did a sizeable amount of business with state government hospitals and health centers. Mr. Sharma had given a lot of freedom to field sales agents to strike deals and negotiate prices with clients. This strategy worked well for the company. Recently Mr. Sharma received word that three company employees were selling products to government hospitals and health centers at a higher price than they were selling to other private hospitals and health centers. The employees were with the company for over five years and were good performers. A few sales staff informally raised the issue of the three getting relatively higher commissions because of their inflated deals. And this was creating a sense of unease among the sales staff. A cursory review of the account of the three showed that, in many instances, the government hospitals were paying more than other private institutions. Under procurement rules, the government is supposed to pay a fair price, one that other cost-conscious customers pay. On inquiry, Mr. Sharma found that the three were not alone; government purchase department officials were helping them scam the Department. Mr. Sharma realized that his sales staff and some corrupt government staff had been defrauding the state exchequer for quite some time. Mr. Sharma immediately reported it to his CEO, and the two discussed how to deal with the sales staff and whether to inform the government about the scam and the involvement of their staff. The issue was informing the government means that there was every possibility that they might be blacklisted, thereby losing a lot of business. Mr. Sharma and CEO were caught in a dilemma regarding how to proceed with the case. (a) What are the ethical and business issues involved in the case? (b) What are the options available to Mr. Sharma and the CEO? (c) Do you think the organizational culture of giving freedom to the sales force led to the issue or was the individual's corrupt nature that led to the problem? Discuss. (d) What ethics mechanisms and steps can the company create and implement to prevent unethical behavior, as mentioned in the case?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The given case is one of corruption by certain govt officials, in collusion with pvt agents - to waste taxpayer money paid by ordinary hardworking citizens It is amongst the highest of all crimes in govt administration

(a) Ethical issues 1. Mis-selling by company sales agents 2. Company sales agents getting higher commission for mis-selling -> perverse incentives 3. Corruption by govt officials 4. Govt hospital forced to buy medicine at higher price 5. State exchequer scammed. 6. Tax payer money wasted. 7. Govt audit/internal vigilance mechanisms failed

Business issues 1. Business considerations v/s ethical considerations 2. Profit v/s transparency 3. Concern amongst Mr Sharma and CEO about being blacklisted for doing the right thing Ideally, State should create an environment where people feel confident about doing the right thing, and apprehensive about wrong thing.

(b) Options available 1. Do nothing (neither fire employees, nor inform govt) 2. Fire employees, not inform govt 3. Fire employees, inform govt, file case under POCA 1988

Chosen course of action The best course of action would be Option 3

1. Employees should be fired => to set an example, to ensure there is no wrongdoing again 2. Govt should be informed -> W.D Ross prima facie principle of beneficence, honesty -> deontological (duty), teleological (benefit) ethics. -> if govt finds out later, the firm may also be implicated, and get in more trouble 3. POCA 1988 (prevention against corruption) case should be filed, against said employees as well as the govt servants.

(c) Organizational culture or individual corrupt nature The problem was due to individuals' corrupt nature:

1. Org culture of giving operational freedom is important, for getting the best out of employees, -> also for providing employees opportunity to learn 2. It is in line with principle of subsidiarity 3. Yet, it must be accompanied with checks and balances 4. In this case, it is clearly a case of corrupt nature as: -> only 3 employees doing such fraud -> no empathy for state finances -> no concern for consequences in blind greed. Such corrupt employees must be punished

(d) Ethics measures and steps to be taken 1. Compulsory ethics training Eg: along the lines of compulsory training required for POSH Act. 2. Employees may be asked to repeat above training every year 3. Above training to have case studies and examples - of behaviours not to be followed 4. Swift punishment to guilty - highlighting their examples - (behavioural economics) to discourage repeat offenders 5. Internal audit - regular.

These steps will improve organisational integrity