Topper Copies

Promoting National interest and gaining influence and power in the International arena are the two basic mantras of every country's external policy. Since the last decade, country ABC has aggressively pursued power and expanded its business interests overseas. One of the businesses ABC was interested in developing was Defence equipment and Satellite technology. It was seeking markets for its space and defense products. The country encouraged its defense equipment manufacturing companies to find new markets and explore manufacturing collaborations with other countries. GAMA, one of the major defense equipment manufacturers, had recently struck a massive multi-billion dollar deal involving sensitive technology transfer and equipment with a country XYZ ruled by Military Junta. It was good business. As the business details became public, much criticism came GAMA's way because XYZ was an international pariah because of its poor human rights record. Further, the Junta indulged in a silent genocide of a minority ethnic community. There was a lot of uproar because the deal involved transferring sensitive technology that could be misused in the wrong hands. In short, it was good business but with questionable clients. Meanwhile, the government of ABC kept silent about the GAMA business deal, and other governments interpreted the silence as a subtle way of building relations with a nation that was an international pariah. (a) What are the ethical issues involved in the above case? (b) Do you think corporate businesses such as GAMA must consider international ethics while pursuing business interests? Why/why not? (c) Do you think a corporate's social responsibility extends beyond one's immediate community to the international community? Why/Why not? (d) Do you think the Defence sector companies marketing sensitive technologies must be regulated by their respective governments, or regulation may curtail their entrepreneurial and innovation energy? Discuss.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The given case reminds of transfer of questionable technology by nations such as USA, China and Russia to questionable allies such as Pakistan, etc.

(a) Ethical issues 1. Reckless pursuit of influence and power in international arena 2. Proliferation of weapons technology 3. Poor human rights record, genocide of minority by military junta. 4. To what extent can State interfere in working of a private business? 5. To what extent should private companies be bound by human rights constraints? 6. Who should be the authority to ensure these constraints are adhered to, internationally? 7. Morals v/s building relations with those accused/responsible for genocide 8. Indirectly undermining democracy

(b) Should corporates consider international ethics Extent to which corporate businesses such as GAMA should consider international ethics while pursuing business interests:

They should consider: 1. In context of violence/war Eg: arms export 2. In context of human rights violations. Eg: forced labour. 3. In context of sustainable development and pollution Eg: mining (cross-border), CBDR principles. 4. In context of labour rights: Eg: fair wages, working hours, etc. 5. In context of adherence to international treaties, conventions. Eg: UNFCCC, or UN-CBD, etc.

Challenges 1. Lack of level playing field, uniform applicability of such ethics by companies. 2. If one company does it, others are forced to do it, to not lose market share/stay competitive. Eg: if one company pollutes environment of foreign country to save costs, so do all other. 3. Selective application of ethics Eg: concern about Blacks in USA, but not about Uighurs in China. (who in fact face much worse abuse) 4. No enforcement

Way forward 1. Common application of ethical principles, by consensus 2. Oversight - objective - by unbiased body -> to prevent proliferation of weapons, etc

(c) Does corporate responsibility extend to the international community Corporate's responsibility beyond immediate community to international community.

1. Problems of world are interconnected, in globalized world. 2. Thus: concentric circles theory of responsibility

As radius of circle increases, responsibility reduces, but does not go away. This is because: "poverty anywhere is threat to prosperity everywhere"

(d) Should defence sector companies be regulated Need for regulation -> to prevent proliferation in wrong hands -> to prevent technology from reaching terrorists "Terrorism is worst abuse of human rights" - S. Jaishankar

Who should regulate -> nation, but there is need for international oversight too, to ensure no company can gain undue advantage

Aforementioned steps from part (b) must be implemented