Topper Copies

You are posted in the Department of Mines, and one of your roles is to help your Department Head negotiate mining leases with private contractors. Recently, the state government demarcated a new mining zone and planned to invite bids for the mining blocs. You were instructed to oversee the bidding process and speed up the contract negotiations. As planned, the tenders were released, bids came in, and tenders were allocated as per the norms. All this happened at a breakneck speed. You wondered, why the hurry? But it was not your place to think and question; you quietly went about your work. As the contractors were about to start operations, you had to instruct them on environmental concerns to watch out for. And to do that, you read the environmental impact assessment report submitted by a consulting firm hired by the department. To your surprise, the report was shoddy and looked cooked up. You got suspicious and raised the issue with your Head, who politely instructed you to do what you were told, and he reminded you that the Department had revenue targets and was under pressure from the Ministry. After the meeting, you, on your own accord, did some digging and found out that the report was fraudulent and the mining activity that was about to start would lead to a massive environmental disaster which the State could not afford. (a) What are the issues and value violations you notice in the above case? (b) What are the options available to you? (c) Discuss the advantage and disadvantages of each option and identify your chosen course of action. (d) Do you think that environmental considerations are sometimes overrated at the cost of development?

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The given case reminds of various ecological disasters due to illegal mining - such as the river floods due to illegal sand mining across the country

(a) Issues 1. Pressure to meet revenue targets at the cost of procedure 2. Fraudulent report 3. EIA not done properly. 4. No concern for disaster and its subsequent cost if mining starts

Value violations 1. Integrity - EPA 1986 Act not followed 2. Sustainability - potential disaster if no action 3. Transparency - EIA is built on pillar of transparency, public hearing, etc 4. Breaking the law 5. Against constitution (Article 48A, etc).

(b) Options available 1. Do as asked 2. Attempt to convince the supervisor 3. Resign 4. Whistle blow

(c) Advantages, disadvantages, and chosen course Option 1: Do as asked: Merits: No apparent merit Demerits: -> disaster -> massive cost to state in future (for minor revenue benefit in present). -> against law. (EPA 1986) -> against deontological ethics: duty to follow law -> against teleological ethics: future cost will outweigh present benefit

Option 2: Attempt to convince supervisor. Merits: -> may lead to new bidding with proper procedure -> future cost saved -> will ensure environment is not harmed Demerits: -> Head may not agree (supervisor).

Option 3: Resign: Merit: personal integrity safeguarded Demerits: other demerits remain from option I

Option 4: Whistle blow: Merit: same as option 3. Demerit: disciplinary action potentially, etc

Course of action 1. I would first attempt to take my findings to my Head, and explain to him gravity of the issue 2. I would inform him that criminal action may be taken against us, for fraudulent EIA, according to EPA 1986. 3. I would also inform him - we may be potentially rewarded - for saving the state from future costs. 4. However, if I am not able to convince - I would take Option 4, ie whistleblowing as a last resort

(d) Are environmental considerations sometimes overrated Yes, environmental considerations are sometimes overlooked.

1. We follow anthropocentric approach to environmental ethics. 2. Environment is seen as a means. 3. Short term benefits outweigh the long term repurcussions. 4. Hence, environmental concerns are overlooked.

We must realize: "No matter what we do, we cannot destroy the environment fully, but if she so desires, environment can destroy us completely" and "Earth is not a gift from ancestors, but a debt from our descendents"