The Constitution envisages the principle of federal supremacy in the executive space of Indian federal polity. Discuss while referring to the relevant Constitutional provisions and case laws. How are contentious issues regarding the distribution of powers resolved?
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Article 1 states that India is a union of states highlighting its quasi federal nature which is most evident in the executive space.
Principle of federal Supremacy
Gives supremacy to the union over the states in certain matters to ensure unity & integrity of the nation.
Constitutional provisions
1. Office of governor: who is appointed by the union as its representative in the state enjoys.
2. All India Service: officers are appointed by the union and serve in the state and can be removed only by the president 3. Advisory role: the union government can issue advisories to the state on subjects such as maintainence of railways, welfare of tribals, etc. 4. Emergency powers: Under article 352 the entire polity is turned into a unitary state and under article 356, state government is dismissed for failure of constitutional machinery.
Case Laws
1. In the recent SC judgement on abrogation of special status of J&K, the SC upheld the union government's authority to dissolve a state 2. In the NCT Case the SC recognised Lt Governor of Delhi as the final executive authority.
Resolution of Contentious Issues
1. Institutional forums: like the Inter state Council and zonal councils can act as forum for dialogue. 2. Judiciary: the SC under article 131 enjoys original jurisdiction over intergovernmental disputes. eg recently SC ruled royalty is not a tax, giving financial power to states 3. NITI's Aayog: strives to encourage cooperative federalism through its governing council
Federalism is part of the basic structure of the constitution (SR Bommai case), we must practice cooperative & enabling federalism rather than combative & extractive federalism.