A certain State government was running a welfare scheme for promoting safe motherhood among rural landless laborers' families. The scheme involves the transfer of funds to the beneficiaries to enable them to mitigate income loss due to maternal care responsibilities. Since its implementation, the scheme has done reasonably well on maternal health and economic indicators. You are the Director of the Department responsible for implementing and operating the scheme. Recently you have been receiving reports of welfare fraud being committed by families by producing fake bona fide. The families committed the fraud with the help of local officials responsible for scrutinizing the bonafide. You were concerned because the fraud was seriously undermining the scheme's efficiency. You called for a departmental meeting to discuss and find a solution to the problem. In the meeting, it was decided to merge several available government data sets such as Aadhar cards, voter ID cards, marriage certificates, birth certificates, bank details, and other personal assets. By merging all the data sets, the department would be able to develop the beneficiary's economic profile. And this will help the department scrutinize the documents and detect fraud. This was a comprehensive strategy, but it risked violating an individual's data privacy. As a Department head, you wanted to detect and prevent fraud, but at the same time, you were apprehensive about violating the Data privacy of the stakeholders. (a) What are the issues involved in the above case? (b) Do you think violating data privacy is justified to prevent welfare fraud? Why/Why not? (c) What, according to you, can be the reasons for such welfare frauds happening in the country? (d) Are there any ways and means to prevent such fraud? Give your suggestions.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The given case reminds of Supreme Court judgement in the Aadhaar case - privacy may be violated only if the benefits sought cannot be achieved any other way, and the objective is a necessity
(a) Issues involved 1. Efficiency v/s privacy 2. Right to maternity relief (Article 41) v/s Right to life (covering right to privacy) (Article 21) 3. (imp) Conflict of W.D Ross prima facie principles: principle of beneficence (to ensure scheme achieves its objectives) v/s principle of non-maleficence (to ensure there is no collateral damage). 4. Integrity (to ensure zero leakage) v/s empathy (towards privacy of beneficiaries) 5. Potential violation of privacy of all just because of few bad apples
(b) Is the compromise justified Compromise of data privacy to prevent welfare fraud, only if:
1. No other alternative 2. The scale of the fraud justifies such action 3. Such violation of privacy will not have a disproportionately high impact on any other sphere of life. (doctrine of proportionality) 4. In such a situation, utilitarian principles (maximum benefit for maximum number of people) justify such action 5. Deontological/Kantian principles - adherence to duty - also justify such action
However, if the extent of fraud is minor, or if only few people are involved, and taking the action will also penalize those not involved, then compromise would not be justified.
(c) Reasons for such frauds On part of the govt officials involved: 1. Lack of ethics/morals in those govt officials 2. Lack of emotional intelligence about the impact of their actions 3. "Culture of corruption" 4. Moral bankruptcy 5. Inefficient vigilance mechanism of govt.
On part of the citizens involved 1. Desire to make "quick money" 2. Unemployment in society 3. Loopholes in schemes which are exploited by citizens
Issues in scheme design itself: 1. Loopholes. 2. Lack of clarity/ambigious definitions 3. Untrained bureaucrats/politicians who design such schemes (lack of expertise)
(d) Ways and means to prevent such fraud Societal solution: 1. Build moral and ethical capital in society 2. Moral education amongst youth 3. Societal vigilance: Eg: SECC census: details of census published in Gram Sabha -> anyone may object 4. Similarly, details of beneficiaries may be given to Gram Sabha: if any one is a bogus beneficiary -> Gram Sabha may highlight (in line with Gandhian principle of trusteeship and Gram Swaraj)
Within govt: 1. Stricter punishments to corrupt officials 2. Better vigilance.
Technological solutions: 1. Surveillance using data, as mentioned in case. 2. DBT
Better design of laws, schemes - no loopholes
These steps will help reduce such fraud, and strengthen govt institutions, in line with SDG 16