Topper Copies

You are a young officer working with the Municipal Corporation of an industrial city. The city was known for manufacturing ball bearings and auto parts. Most manufacturing units were small scale units with very little production process automation. The units relied on manual labor, which was in abundance due to the villages close by. As the number of manufacturing units grew, the demand for labor increased, bringing in a steady inflow of laborers into the city. This influx of people into the town led to a mushrooming of slums and encroachments on the sidewalks. Once in a while, the Corporation conducted drives to clear out the slums, but after a time, the slums came back. The illegal slums had become an urban nightmare. You were given the responsibility of clearing out the encroachments and slums with the help of Police authorities. As you started the drive, you realized that the people living by the sidewalks were vulnerable compared to the slum dwellers. Many sidewalk dwellers had recently come to the city after selling their properties in their villages. Now if you drive them out, they have no place to go. Your heart went out to them, and you felt that your departmental action was inhumane, but your official responsibilities demanded stern impartial action. You are desperate to find a way to help the sidewalk dwellers without compromising your official duties. (a) What value conflicts do you notice in the above situation? (b) Can an administrator compromise the value of impartiality for empathy? Discuss. (c) What are the options available in the above situation? (d) Suggest viable solutions for tackling illegal slums and encroachments in urban areas.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

The given case study reminds of the harmful effects of gentrification on the local inhabitants; and also of cases related to incomplete rehabilitation for developmental projects.

(a) Value conflicts in given situation 1. Principle of adherence to duty v/s empathy and compassion. 2. Ethical dilemma: deontological ethics (duty based) v/s teleological ethics (benefit based). 3. Crisis of conscience: thoughts and deeds not in consonance. 4. Right to shelter of slum and sidewalk dwellers v/s right to movement, etc of city inhabitants. 5. (imp) Value of administrative impartiality v/s ethical governance 6. Weberian bureaucracy v/s ethical bureaucracy

(b) Can impartiality be compromised for empathy For Administrators, impartiality and empathy are both foundational values.

Administrator may compromise on impartiality for empathy but only as if

1. As a last resort 2. Not compromising would lead to grave injustice 3. The compromise is proportional to the benefit the administrator seeks to achieve (doctrine of proportionality) 4. The administrator shall take all possible steps to take empathatic action within the boundary of impartiality (doctrine of harmonious construction) 5. Administrator must immediately inform the govt/courts (ie) uphold accountability 6. Administrator must make a solid case based on teleological ethics, (ie) do objective analysis of the benefit his action will achieve for society 7. Buddhism's "doctrine of skillful means" - supports such compromise in situations such as these 8. Bhagavad Gita's principle of "sthaan, kaal, patra" also is in consonance with compromise in such situations

(c) Options available 1. Disobey the order 2. Follow the order in letter and spirit 3. Find a middle path.

Possible middle path action (in above situation) 1. Work with ball bearings and auto parts manufacturers for temporary assistance. (which employ the labourers) 2. Jointly approach the municipal administration for long term solution. 3. Displacement of labourers will directly harm the economy in this case - lead to unemployment 4. Possible slum redevelopment project in long term - involving govt as well as CSR funds 5. Supreme court judgement: Rajesh K Singh v/s State of UP (2019) - Right to shelter is a fundamental right, no one can be forcibly evicted (under Article 21) -> use this judgement for rehabilitation.

(d) Viable solutions for tackling illegal slums Short term: -> time bound formalizations. Odisha: JAGA Mission -> 30 sq ft land title. -> "slum to livable habitat" -> acknowledges slum dwellers as city makers (Received UN Habitat Award)

Long term -> slum redevelopment Eg: Dharavi -> Transit Oriented development - Budget 2022 -> development of public transport.

Aforementioned steps will help achieve SDG 10 and sustainable cities