Assess the effectiveness of the Right to Information Act, 2005 in ensuring transparency and accountability in governance in the last two decades. (Answer in 250 words)
Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025
The Right to Information Act of 2005 was a landmark legislation that operationalised the right to know u/Article 19(a)
Effectiveness of RTI in ensuring transparency and accountability 1. Section 2 of the RTI act makes it a legal right to seek information 2. Section 7 imposes timelines on the Public information officers 3. It has been able to expose irregularities in governance eg PDS Ghost Cards in Bihar 4. It has identified corrupt practices and diversion of funds eg Diversion of Mid-Day meal funds in Odisha 5. Section 4 suggests proactive disclosure by public institutions which enhances Transparency 6. Accessible online RTI portal has made usage of RTI Act easier.
However, there have been several limitations to the RTI Act 1. Increased usage of exemption clauses under sections 8 & sections 11 2. Secrecy clause under section 24 reduces citizens access to certain information 3. Delays in responses to the RTIs by PIOs 4. Understaffed central and state Information Commissions (CIC & SIC) 5. Concerns over independence of CIC & SIC & appointment processes
Way Forward 1. Using e-governance to improve RTI effectiveness eg Jharkhand's Jharsewa Portal 2. Global best Practices - Scotland has given constitutional status to information commissions
RTI without independence is like a sword in a scabbard controlled by the very people it was meant to scrutinize