Social transformation programs such as "beti bachao and beti padhao" believes in using advice, counseling, and persuasion but sometimes a little force is also necessary for getting the desired response. Do you think it is a good idea to mix little force with persuasion by public administrators while implementing social schemes of transformation? Explain with relevant examples.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
According to Nobel Prize winning behavioural economist Richard Thaler, who gave the "Nudge theory" - there are 4 ways to bring social transformation
In this context, yes, it is a good idea to mix a little force with persuasion.
All the 4 components must balance and complement each other.
Analysis: in Beti Bachao Beti Padhao -> Legislation: PCPNDT Act, etc -> Education: Awareness campaigns, "Digital Guddi Guddi Board" -> Nudge: "selfie with daughter" -> Enforcement: IPC relevant sections (force)
Analysis: Swachh Bharat -> Legislation: Water Act 1980 -> Education: awareness, ODF, etc -> Nudge: "Darwaza Band" campaign, etc. -> Enforcement: fines for open defecation.
All are needed in harmony as 1. Education: -> creates awareness -> makes people understand pros and cons, etc 2. Legislation: -> creates foundation for administration to act. 3. Nudge: -> pushes people from inertia. -> ensures that habits can change 4. Enforcement: -> plays critical role. -> ensures that any citizens who may not be convinced by above 3 methods do not prevent execution -> create right/wrong in minds of citizens from the point of view of punishment
Hence, little force is needed, but only to the extent that it complements above 3 mechanisms.
If it is overdone => it will backfire. Eg: Child Labour Amendment 2012