The focus of welfare schemes in India is shifting from "well-being" towards "over-dependency". In light of this, do you agree that welfare schemes have inculcated a "freebies culture" in India leading to a divergence of focus from poverty and hunger alleviation?
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
Recently the PM brought attention the revdie culture highlighting issues of dependencies created by welfare schemes.
Welfare schemes & divergence of focus from hunger alleviation + poverty
Arguments in favour
1. Increased expenditure on welfare schemes creates fiscal deficits (FD) eg 4.9% FD in FY24 2. Decreases availability of funds for other programmes eg around 4.5Lcr spent in food fuel fertilizer subsidy (FY24) 3. Increased issue of hunger eg India -> #117 in Global hunger index. 1/3rd kids -> malnutritioned; 50% women and 14% men -> anaemic (NFHS-5) 4. Increased issue of poverty eg NITI Aayog MDPI -> 16% population poor.
Arguments Against
1. Welfare schemes address hunger
2. Empower citizens to reduce poverty
Welfare schemes should be properly implemented to reduce leakages and periodically monitored to ensure intended beneficiaries prosper so that we can achieve our SDG (1) (poverty) & SDG 2 (hunger).