Assess the implications of the 103rd Constitutional Amendment, which introduced a ten per cent reservation for Economically Weaker Sections (EWS), on the principle of social justice in India.
Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024
As per the recommendations of the Sinhos Committee the GoI passed the 103CAA to provide 10% reservation to EWS in public employment and educational institutions.
Implications
Positive
1. Ensure economic justice for the EWS. eg per capita income in India is around 2L/annum 2. Provide opportunity for social mobility 3. Realise value of equality of opportunity in preamble 4. Help decrease income inequality eg top 1% in India -> 40% of wealth. 5. Help decrease poverty eg 16% population poor multidimensionally (NITI)
Negative
1. Exceeds the 50% limit laid down by SC in Indra Sawhney judgement 2. Priorities equity + equality over limit 3. Difficulties in identification of beneficiaries eg issues of fake certificates 4. Economic class as a criteria for affirmative action is not explicitly mentioned in the constitution 5. Excludes only a few as more than 80% population -> EWS 6. Decreases pool of seats for SC/ST/OBCs.
The beauty of any policy lies in its implementation, the SC has upheld the validity of 103CAA, now the GoI must ensure its benefits reach intended beneficiaries.