You are the newly appointed Superintendent of Police (SP) of Puri district, Odisha, brought in after a tragic stampede during the recent Rath Yatra festival that claimed three lives and injured over fifty devotees. An official inquiry cited serious lapses in crowd control, poor coordination among police units, and the controversial prioritization of VIP access over the safety of ordinary devotees as contributing factors. With three more major rituals of the Rath Yatra scheduled over the next week, and a turnout expected to cross 10 lakh devotees, you are tasked with ensuring foolproof security and achieving zero casualties. As you prepare the revised plan for crowd management, you are faced with a new challenge: a senior cabinet minister's office sends a firm message requesting unrestricted VIP access for several high-profile guests, citing their contributions to temple development. The minister emphasizes that these guests must be given safe, fast-track access to the rituals, particularly during peak hours, for "security and protocol reasons." You are discreetly informed that failure to comply may reflect poorly on your "team spirit" and "coordination." However, in coordination meetings, your technical team strongly recommends a complete ban on VIP movement as well as restricted public access during peak hours. Your technical team reiterates that strict movement controls and complete exclusion of VIP corridors during peak hours are essential to prevent another tragedy. Even a group of local journalists and civil society activists approach you to acknowledge institutional lapses earlier and ban all elite access in solidarity with the victims' families, failing which, they threaten to make public compelling evidence that police personnel ignored crowd warnings during the stampede. Moreover, there is also discomfort among religious leaders of the area regarding heavy restrictions, fearing it may disturb centuries-old ritual sanctity. You must now take a final decision that could either uphold the principle of equity and public safety or preserve traditional hierarchies and personal rapport with the political leadership. (a) What are the ethical dilemmas that you face? (b) What are the options available to you to cope with this situation? (c) Which of the options, do you think, would be the most appropriate for you to adopt and why? (d) What systemic reforms would you suggest for the long-term resolution of such challenges in managing large religious gatherings, particularly concerning VIP access as well as public safety?
Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025
This case is an example of the political apathy and the dichotomy between following orders and saving public interest
(a) Ethical dilemmas 1. Lapses in crowd control vs VIP movement 2. Political pressure vs Public safety 3. Professional duty to public vs consequence to self 4. Advise of technical team vs senior orders
(b) Options Available - Not allowing VIP entry and focus on safety - Allowing VIP entry
(c) Most appropriate option 1. Requesting written order from senior minister 2. If written order is not received - ban VIP Movement
(d) Systemic Reforms - Following NDMA guidelines - Ending VIP culture - Increasing accountability
With these measures we can ensure safety in public places