You have recently been appointed as the Chief Secretary of a state. Soon after, you receive multiple reports highlighting instances of unprofessional conduct by several civil servants, including officers of the All India Services. These include publicly displaying political allegiance at government functions, engaging in culturally inappropriate gestures such as touching political leaders' feet, and posting controversial or sensitive opinions on social media platforms that could be interpreted as partisan and breach of civil service norms. These actions have triggered criticism from the public and media, raising concerns about the erosion of the neutrality, integrity, and discipline expected of public servants. You believe that these actions, if left unchecked, could damage the credibility of the administration and the trust reposed in it by the people. You now face the challenge of taking corrective measures to ensure that such incidents are not repeated, while also maintaining morale within the services and avoiding overly harsh or demotivating actions. (a) What are the ethical concerns in this case? (b) As the Chief Secretary, what steps should you take to address the situation? (c) How can a balance be maintained between respecting personal freedom and upholding professional standards of civil servants?
Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025
The case presents the increasing problem of loss of credibility & reputation of the Public services
(a) Ethical concerns in the case 1. Unprofessional conduct by civil servants. 2. Violation of political neutrality by civil servants 3. Erosion of Integrity in public services 4. Indication of Bureaucrat-Politician nexus 5. Sensitive opinions on social media - breach of official impartiality & confidentiality 6. Loss of public trust and falling credibility of the public services
(b) Steps to address situation 1. Identifying civil servants who have violated code of conduct 2. Giving them an official warning regarding their conduct 3. Mandating refresher courses for them under Mission Karmayogi 4. Taking a state-wide round to inspect work culture among other civil servants 5. Pushing for a code of Ethics at the institutional level
(c) Balance between personal freedom & professional standards 1. Compartmentalisation of Public & private life 2. Reducing impact of personal choices in professional acts and vice versa 3. Conducting workshops for regular training 4. Creation of a code of ethics that accomodates personal freedom.
The need is for a balanced work culture and out of work life for civil servants