Goodness is the result of internal imperatives to do what is right, not sanctions from moral rules or rewards from expected consequences. Do you agree? Discuss.
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
The given statement is based on Aristotelean ethics or "Virtue ethics".
For most part, yes, I agree with the statement:
1. It is inherent goodness of character that leads to "goodness of action" 2. Cardinal values are thus based on the principle -> Justice, Temperence, Courage, Prudence 3. If internal imperative is present, external circumstances do not impact the actions Eg: good samaritans help accident victims irrespective of external rules. 4. Hence, there are many cases of whistleblowers: despite possible moral/legal sanctions, whistleblowers release information for social good 5. There are many cases wherein strangers return wallets/lost properties to police/owners - without expectation of reward 6. Thus, lost and found rooms - at railway stations, etc are based on this principle. 7. Civil servants display courage of conviction - foundational value - to do what is right - irrespective of any fear or favour.
Yet, at the same time, there are also instances of goodness outside of internal imperatives.
1. Goodness due to social pressure, peer pressure Eg: Charity. 2. Corporate Social Responsibility - due to statutory laws 3. Use of Nudge, behavioural economics - recommended by Economic Surveys Eg: to improve tax compliance.
Hence, goodness while mostly from internal imperatives, can exist everywhere.