Topper Copies

There is a need to shift the focus of Section 8 of the Representation of People Act, 1951 from the duration of the sentence to the gravity of the offence. Comment on how the current classification under Section 8 leads to arbitrary categorisation of offences. Also, mention the remedies available to a person disqualified under this section.

Ashi Sharma, AIR 12, 2024

The rising criminalisation of politics and politicisation of criminals has led to the demand of re-evaluating section 8 of RPA 1951.

Current Classification

1. S8 outlines some heinous and serious offences (eg. rape, sati etc) for which the MP/MLA will be disqualified for contesting polls for the duration of sentence + 6yrs post the sentence

[bar chart: % of MPs with criminal record rising across Lok Sabha terms - 20%, 24%, 30%, 34%, 43%, 46%]

2. For other offences with a punishment of fine or sentence <2yr, the candidates will be disqualified only for the duration of the sentence

3. However, no objective classification exists and often subjectivity is misused to get a less harsh sentence & escape disqualification

Resolution

1. New categorisation based on escalation matrix to penalise candidates based on gravity of their offence rather than sentence of punishment

Remedies

1. Disqualified candidates can approach higher judiciary and make an appeal. eg Lakshadweep MP was accused under S(8), appealed and got it overturned 2. ECI also reserves right to stay the order of disqualification

Nevertheless there is an urgent need to reform S(8) and also undertake steps to decriminalise politics