Mohit is the Deputy Commissioner of a prominent industrial district in India. The largest industrial unit in this district is a steel making public sector undertaking which was established three decades ago. During the establishment of the PSU, large number of families were displaced and in return they were promised jobs in this unit. Subsequently, a large group of displaced youth was also trained under the PSU's apprenticeship programme. While the PSU had assured them jobs after completing apprenticeship training, most trained individuals remained unemployed, with many now over 45 years old and unable to find jobs elsewhere. For nine years, the unemployed individuals have been demanding permanent employment but to no avail. Finally, they resorted to protests outside the establishment. The protesters blocked the main gate, obstructing employee movement and disrupting operations. The Central Industrial Security Force (CISF) resorted to a lathi charge to disperse the crowd, resulting in the death of a 23-year-old protester. The protests escalated, with demonstrators damaging a canal supplying water to the plant. The steel plant is a thermo-sensitive facility with highly sensitive gas pipelines, and any leak could pose a serious threat to public safety. Further, with the blockade continuing for over 18 hours, nearly 5,000 employees remain trapped inside without access to food and water, significantly impacting plant operations. Mohit needs to placate the protestors as they are threatening to go on a prolonged protest. At the same time, the plant should be kept operational to prevent any critical industrial and public safety risk. (a) What are the ethical dilemmas that Mohit faces? (b) Discuss all the options available to Mohit as the Deputy Commissioner. (c) What course of action should Mohit take given the critical nature of the situation?
Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025
This case presents a situation where the right to protest and social harmony find each other at the crossroads.
(a) Ethical dilemmas faced by Mohit 1. Concerns over brutality in security forces action 2. Protection of innocent employees trapped vs Right to protest 3. Social safety vs Right to protest 4. Law and order disruptions vs expression of dissent 5. Employement & economic rights vs operationality of steel plant.
(b) Options available to Mohit 1. Order security forces to disperse the protesting crowd | Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Saves trapped employees | Against Democratic ethics | | Keeps plant operational | Does not address economic injustice | 2. Let the protest continue | Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Respects rights of protestors | Violence may increase | | Holds PSU accountable | Threat to trapped employees | 3. Negotiating a temporary truce to allow employees to leave and then let protests continue | Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Saves 5000 employees | The issue of violence may persist | | Allows protests for economic rights | Plant may not remain operational |
(c) Suggested Course of Action
Justification - This action shows compassion and concern for public safety. It also protects economic rights while preserving law & order