Technical efficiency ensures resource utilization and social efficiency ensures fulfillment of social needs, what does ethical efficiency ensure? Do you think ethical efficiency is more important than technical and social efficiency? Why/Why not?
Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023
Ethical efficiency is the missing piece of the puzzle that ensures technical and social efficiency accomplish the goal of national progress
Technical efficiency ensuring resource utilization -> Human resource: Eg: Agnipath in armed forces -> Economic resource: Eg. audit by CAG -> Social resources: Eg. Darpan Portal by NITI Aayog to work with NGOs, etc.
Social efficiency ensures fulfilment of social needs -> Social justice: Eg: Reservation in education -> Social development: Eg: access to healthcare via PM-JAY. -> Social security: Eg: MGNREGA as safety net -> Social audit
Yet, without ethical efficiency, they are incomplete:
1. Development must be in line with the ethical and cultural context. Eg: Panchsheel for tribal development 2. Hence, Kautilya said: progress must keep in mind -> Trayi (cultural context), -> Varta (policy), -> Dandneeti (enforcement), -> Anvikshiki (philosophical and ethical framework) 3. In the same context, Thiruvalluvar in Thirukkural - focused on ethical governance, as re-iterated by Finance Minister. 4. Ethical efficiency ensures no one is left behind - Sarvodaya, Antyodaya 5. Ethical efficiency is based on relational ethics: a different approach may be needed for development of some section of population - depending on their relationship with the state. Eg: for North East 6. Hence, the theme of Budget 2023 was - "Trust based governance" - to bring ethical efficiency in administration.
Thus, yes, ethical efficiency is more important, as without it, the other two are incomplete Hence, focus must shift to steps such as outcome budget, MISSION LIFE, etc