Topper Copies

The Chief Election Commissioner and Other Election Commissioners Act, 2023 has sparked concerns about the erosion of the Election Commission's autonomy. Critically examine. (Answer in 150 words)

Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025

The Chief Election Commissioner and other Election Commissioner Act, 2023 created a committee to appoint election commissioners.

Composition of Committee - Hon'ble Prime Minister - Leader of opposition - One Union minister

Concerns about erosion of the Election Commission's Autonomy 1. Exclusion of Judiciary from the appointment process raises concern 2. Reverses the courts' decision in the Anoop Baranwal Case which proposed a different committee 3. Complete executive control over appointment may lead to loss of Independence. 4. Concerns regarding the opacity of the recommendation process

However, a counterview also exists 1. Precedent - appointments by the executive have led to fair elections 2. Constitutional safeguards under Article 324 will ensure autonomy 3. In the past, successful role models like TN Seshan have been appointed by the executive.

Since the matter is now sub-Judice in the Jaya Thakur case it is prudent to wait for the court's advice