How does the federal structure of India differ from that of the United States? (Answer in 150 words)
Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025
India is described as an Indestructible union of destructible states.
USA is described as a destructible Union of Indestructible states
Differences in the federal structure
| Parameter | India | USA | |---|---|---| | 1. Constitution | Single common constitution for Union & States | Seperate Federal and state level constitution | | 2. Representation | In Rajya Sabha based on the population | 2 seats for every state in the state | | 3. Governor | Appointed by the President | Elected by the citizens of the state | | 4. Laws | Separated into Lists by the 7th schedule | Constitution of state gives extensive powers | | 5. Judiciary | Integrated and Independent Judiciary for both central & state laws | Seperate Federal & state level Judiciary catering to seperate laws | | 6. Amendments | Only federal portions need state approval | All amendments require approval of states |
However there are some similarities - Centre controls defence and Foreign affairs - Bicameral legislatures
Thus India and USA have two very different approaches towards federalism.