Topper Copies

What do you understand by "integrity-based civil disobedience"? Do you think a challenge to personal integrity can be a justifiable cause for responsible disobedience in civil services? Explain.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Civil disobedience is the active or passive refusal by a citizen to disobey certain laws/orders of the government, that are deemed to be unethical/immoral.

"Integrity based civil disobedience" is civil disobedience which follows 3 principles (as according to John Rawls):

1. The law/order being opposed is leading to direct injustice. 2. There is no alternative, ie, civil disobedience is being used as a last resort 3. It is being used in a way that will not destabilize general law and order.

In some situations, yes, challenge to personal integrity can be justifiable cause for responsible disobedience.

1. When aforementioned 3 principles by John Rawls are met. 2. ie -> all other possibilities have been exhausted -> it will not lead to disproportionate harm. 3. Integrity is one of foundational values according to 2nd ARC, Nolan committee, etc; hence challenge to integrity may be justifiable cause. 4. Challenge to personal integrity may lead to crisis of conscience. 5. Challenge to integrity => may lead to societal harm Eg: whistleblowing about violation of privacy by Edward Snowden 6. In the same context, Gandhiji undertook civil disobedience. However, Gandhiji ensured it is in line with principles of John Rawls. Eg: emphasis on peaceful picketing. 7. Supreme court and High courts have upheld freedom of expression of public servants

However, civil servants must exercise such action with caution, only as a last resort, and after ensuring that the national interest and law and order will not be affected.