Topper Copies

You are the District Collector of Malinar, a coastal district in Kerala. The Government of India has recently implemented a nationwide ban on bottom trawling under the Marine Fisheries (Regulation & Management) Rules, 2024, citing serious ecological damage caused by the practice. However, in Malinar district, a majority of the traditional fishing community has relied solely on bottom trawling for decades. Most fishermen possess only trawling boats and lack the training or resources to transition to alternative practices. The situation has intensified ahead of the upcoming United Nations Environment Programme (UNEP) "Oceans for Tomorrow" Conference, to be hosted in Kochi. The central government wants to showcase strict enforcement and marine conservation achievements. You receive a formal directive from the State Secretariat to take strict legal action, including seizure of boats and arrests, against fishermen found violating the ban. Simultaneously, a confidential note warns you that any negative media attention or footage of illegal trawling from your district could "embarrass the state" and jeopardize national image at the global forum. Local tensions rise as environmental NGOs begin posting satellite-based evidence of illegal trawling. Fishermen's cooperatives are protesting, arguing that they have no alternative source of income, and any seizure of boats will push hundreds into destitution. They threaten to block access to the district harbour and dump fish waste outside government offices if strict enforcement continues. (a) Who are the principal stakeholders in this case? Analyse their perspectives and conflicting interests. (b) As the District Collector, what are the various options available to you to address the situation? Evaluate the merits and demerits of each option. (c) What course of action would you take and why? Justify your decision.

Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025

This case presents a direct conflict between environmental sustainability and traditional livelihoods like Fishing

(a)

Perspectives & corresponding conflicting interests 1. Fishing Community - Depuriation of livelihoods - Absence of sustainable alternatives 2. NGO Activist & Environment - Damage to marine environment must be mitigated - Bottom trawling is not sustainable 3. Government - Preservation of environment - Protecting National image 4. Myself as District Collector - Balancing law & order with social harmony - Protecting both environment & rights of people

(b) Options Available to me 1. Take strict action against Bottom Trawling | Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Protects environment | Against local interests | | Follows orders | Disrupts livelihoods of fishermen | | Shields national image | | 2. Taking no action against fishing | Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Protects local rights | Harms the environment | | Protects livelihoods of fishermen | Violates orders | | | Damages national image | 3. Negotiate with fishing community to stop bottom trawling for a week & form a task force to explore options | Merits | Demerits | |---|---| | Discourse ethics | Bureaucratic delay | | Follows orders | Temporary pause | | Preserves Image | |

(c) My Course of Action

Justification - My action protects national image while preserving the economic security of fishing community. It also aims to find sustainable alternatives to support both economy & environment