Topper Copies

Siddharth, a 13-year-old school student, has been arrested for the fatal stabbing of his classmate Saumya after a series of bullying incidents at school and on social media. Investigations reveal that Siddharth was the target of a sustained cyberbullying campaign, including derogatory remarks and the circulation of his private images without consent. Further inquiry reveals that Siddharth was under immense peer pressure and was handed a weapon by his classmates, who believed he would only use it to scare Saumya. Siddharth's emotional distress had gone unnoticed by both his parents and school authorities. The community is now sharply divided. While some blame the school's failure to intervene, others blame the role of digital platforms, and poor parenting. Siddharth's parents express regret for not noticing signs of emotional breakdown and possible online radicalization. The incident has triggered a wider debate on the ethical responsibilities of schools, parents, digital platforms, and the justice system when dealing with children and social media. (a) Discuss the key ethical issues involved in this case. (b) Analyze the role of peers in influencing adolescent decision-making. (c) Discuss the evolving nature of responsibilities of parents and schools in helping adolescents deal with situations of emotional distress.

Akshit Bhardwaj, AIR 12, 2025

This case highlights the impact of digital platforms and parenting in shaping the minds of children

(a) Ethical issues involved in the case 1. Cyberbullying - leading to loss of dignity 2. Violence and fatal stabbing of a classmate 3. Circulation of images without consent - violation of privacy 4. Issues with digital spaces - echo chambers & Radicalisation 5. Peer pressure and instigation leading to immoral actions 6. Poor parenting - limited awareness about child's mental health 7. Institutional Apathy - schools failure to intervene 8. Issues with Pedagogy - lack of moral education in schools

(b) Role of Peers in influencing adolescent decision making 1. We learn by imitating our social surroundings - Bandura's theory of social learning 2. Our morals develop by interactions & affirmations - Kohlberg's theory of Moral Development 3. Tendency to seek social approval - susceptible to peer pressure 4. Direct source of information & behaviour is the peer group 5. Constant discussions can nudge adolescents towards confirmation bias

(c) Evolving Nature of Responsibilities

of Parents 1. Active engagement with children 2. Focus on emotional discussions 3. Regulating their digital exposure 4. Imparting emotional intelligence 5. Attitude innoculation to prevent radicalisation

of schools 1. Regular assessment of mental health 2. Promoting anti-bullying squads 3. Re-inventing Pedagogy to include moral learning 4. Learning from global best practices eg Sweden's Ed schools

Thus we must re-invent the wheel of parenting & schooling