Critically examine Malthus's theory of population. How far is it relevant today?
Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023
Thomas Robert Malthus - gave his theory in "Essay on principle of population as it affect the happiness of mankind".
his theory is based on four Cornerstones ->
1. Population rise in Geometric progression (GP) due to passionate behavior of Human beings & high fertility, population rise in GP. 2. food and other resources increase in Arithmetic progression -> But resources increase in AP. Thus few people have to die due to lack of resources like food, safety, etc. 3. Positive checks by Nature -> Before this happens Nature cause death of excess population via - war - disasters - epidemics - accidents , etc 4. Preventive checks by humankind -> if humans can to reduce the speed of population growth , No checks would be done by Nature .
Criticism by Karl Marx
1. GP rise of People -> Not true after Industrial revolution, education, family planning etc. 2. AP rise in resources - After technology rise (eg) Green revolution , No shortage of food . 3. Positive checks by Nature - Can be controlled by technology . Eg COVID controlled by Vaccines . 4. Preventive checks by Man — Create other social problems like Rapes, etc
However, at a broad level, theory of Malthus look true to some extent —
1. GP rise — In least developed countries still population rising fast. Eg Niger – birth rates & child / women. 2. AP rise — Many countries have neglected Green revolution due to issues of Soil salinity and infertility 3. Positive Checks — Poor countries / Poor people still face natural extermination. Eg Tsunami of 2004 & Nicobarese population. 4. Preventive checks — use of Protection, Abortion, etc by Mankind.
So at a broder level Malthus looks right.
Currently India has a demographic dividend. It must utilise it effectively to safeguard itself from Positive checks of Nature!