Topper Copies

Public service requires not merely legal but also morally principled action. Public service requires the public servant to place loyalty to the constitution, laws, and ethical principles. Among the three, which do you think must acquire primacy while carrying out official functions? Why? Discuss.

Kush Motwani, AIR 11, 2023

Public service is provision of public utility, and public goods, by public servants, for economic capital, social capital and human capital development.

Requires loyalty to constitution 1. Has the foundation for public servants to discharge their duty (Articles 311, etc) 2. All actions of public servants must be in line with constitution (Article 13) 3. It has the principles that should guide action (Preamble, Article 37, etc)

Requires loyalty to laws 1. While constitution only provides over-arching setup, it is laws that guide in different situations Eg: Disaster Management Act - guides different officials of their roles during a disaster. Eg: Motor Vehicle Act - has norms for safety, etc. 2. Laws provide the procedure - to maintain social control Eg: Civil Procedure Code, etc 3. Laws define "right and wrong" for citizens, from the point of view of punishment

Loyalty to ethical principles "Law only tells what not to do, it is ethics that tells what to do"

ie. of all possible actions sanctioned by law, there is option 1, option 2, option 3.. Need ethics to choose the right option. Eg: disaster relief.

Constitutional loyalty must acquire primacy 1. Constitution lays down principles - Justice (social, economic, political), Liberty (of thought, expression, etc.), Fraternity, Equality. 2. Lays down rights and duties 3. Core principles are based on societal ethics. Eg: Justice - based on dharma Eg: Equality - based on samta.

Hence, constitutional loyalty is the foundation of ethical governance.