India's territorial disputes after independence were not merely about borders, but also encompass issues of national identity, historical grievances, and geopolitical strategies. Discuss.
Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025
Post 1947 independence, India saw rise in territorial disputes with neighbours.
Reason for territorial disputes
1. Vague division by Britishers eg) Radcliff line on kutch 2. Princely - state : autonomy created conflict 3. Historical treaty by British with china not recognised by PRC
[a rough sketch map of India in a box, labelled Kashmir issue, Johnson, McMahon, China, Nepal, Kalapani, Sir Creek, Bangladesh Enclaves, Katchatheevu, captioned "Border - Issues"]
Border - Issues
4. Territorial Disputes : issue of national Identity
1. Preserve secular fabric of country against Pakistan claim of Religion as basis of control of kashmir 2. To revive Indian lost pride post 1962 setback against China eg) Demand for Aksai Chin 3. Protect Indian oneness against threats to identity es) operation polo for Hyderabad.
Historical grievance : Territorial Disputs
1. Pakistan : due to kashmir non-recognition of accession treaty by hari-Singh 2. China : unacceptance of Johnson and Macmohan line treaty 3. Sri-lanka : katchatteve loss seen as grievance by Tamilian fishmer 4. Unsettled lines : in history dispute of present es) Nepal! kalapani
Geopolitical Strategies
1. China | Salami - slicing : and fire Finger (mao policy) to gain territory through disputes. 2. Containtment : policy by china to contain India rise by keeping it in Border-tension 3. Pakistan : ways to stay relevant in globe by utilizing kashmir -issue 4. for better relation in [neighbourhood] India concession eg) Katchatheva to SL 5. Internal politics dictate raising of issue eg) Yunus rise -> concern for Border enclave agreement.
[ways to resolve disputes]
1. Agreement -> through consensus and amendment eg) Bangladesh - India agreement 2. Special Military Dialogue: to prevent conflict eg) Ind - China 3. Border - Infra development: to prevent any intrusion 4. Bilateral discussion
Thus, as [S. Jaishankar] highlights without peaceful border settlement India can't become [Vishwaguru]