Topper Copies

Critically examine the concept of sankritization and its relevance in understanding the dynamics of cultural change in contemporary India

Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023

Sanskritization was first studied by Prof. MN Srinivas in his study of Coorgs. He observed that lower caste in order to achieve a higher status and position in local caste hierarchy would emulate Brahmins. He called it Brahminization Later he clarified that it can be respect to any dominant Caste preferably dwija or twice born. Thus, when a lower caste or tribe or any other changes its customs, traditions and way of life in direction of a dominant caste, this process is called Sanskritization. As per Prof. MN Srinivas caste mobility in India is not only possible but quite frequent too.

Various factors for Sanskritization are →

1. Economic upliftment – study by William Rowe Naiyyas in UP were Salt workers of before britishers. Their Caste Ranking – 43/46 Post British they became Canal workers, their economic increased. Caste ranking increased to 17/48 2. Political power → As per Prof KM Pannikar → Maraths after occupying political power claimed Khatriya status (initially were of lower caste). 3. Political Patronage → Case Study of 'Kayasthas' were initially shudras, but they were used as Scribes by Alla-ud-din Khilji. He accorded them Vaishya status.

Criticism - 1. As per Dr. SC Dubey - This concept is vague and has no practical usage. 2. As per Prof Yogendra Singh - Sanskrit it & not Caste Mobility is via Westernization Sanskritization. 3. Prof DN Majumdar has highlighted De-Sanskritization of higher caste in UP. 4. Prof. MN Srinivas himself admits that it cannot be applied all over India as No single dominant Caste in entire India.

Relevance in understanding dynamics of culture Change in Contemporary India

1. As per Prof. MN Srinivas - Horizontal Solidarity has become more important than vertical Mobility. This is due to the Vote bank politics present in Indian polity. 2. Due to benefits of reservation, Lower castes and ST, do not want to Sanskritise. 3. However, As per Prof Yogendra Singh in UP → After Sanskritization Lower caste would reach higher status and prestige in society. This would threaten Superiority of higher caste. So they look to westernization to maintain their Superiority. 4. Prof. SL Kali gave concept of Tribalization which is a form of De-Sanskritization. where Higher caste of UP would take tribal cultures of Khasa tribe. 5. As per Prof NK Bose - Juang look to cultivation and got inducted as Lower caste in Caste hierarchy.

Thus Sanskritization helps us to understand various facets of Culture change.