Write a note of Jajmani system and examine the views on jajmani system as an egalitarian and as an exploitative system and give reasons for its decline
Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023
Jajmani system was first studied by William Wiser in his book "The Hindu Jajmani system". He did this study in Karimpur village in UP.
(JS)
Jajmani system is the exchange of goods and services between landowning high caste and landless lower caste / artisan caste.
As per Prof Yogendra Singh it is a system of reciprocity.
As per Mandelbaum JS works at family level.
Characteristic of JS
1. Permanent ties - Jajmani ties are permanent in nature. 2. Hereditary relations - Jajmani ties are inherited via hereditary. 3. Exchange of goods and services between Jajman and Kamin 4. Paternalism - As per William Wiser Jajman takes care of Kamin's family. He protects them from exploitation.
Jajmani as Exploitative system
1. As per Beidelman -> JS is exploitative because, Kamin has no choice to come out of JS. Untouchability persists and cannot be removed. 2. As per Opler and Singh after their studies of Eastern Indian villages - Kamin is paid as per his "value" in eyes of Jajman. This leads to exploitation. 3. As per Prof DN Majumdar -> Kamin has to face haraasment from jajman. 4. According to Pauline Kolenda - Jajman value Kamin when his manual labour is required. And at other times discard him.
Jajmani as Egalitarian
1. As per Henry Orenstein -> In JS Kamin can get objects / goods which otherwise he could not have got. 2. Louis dumont considers it as a way of division of labour. 3. As per William Wiser JS benifits both Jajman as well as Kamin.
Reasons for decline of JS
1. Post Globalization -> The Info Landowning caste now produce for the markets. Thus Informal heridity Jajmani ties turn to Formal Contracted obligations 2. Due to Modernization and Industrialization Karvino/Artisan caste have to compete with machines. - Eg Kahar - Hand pumps - Dhobi - Washing Machine 3. Wage Labour has become more attractive than jajmani system. As per N. Narsimhan Reddy due to MGNREGA JS has weakened.
Due to all these factors Jajmani system which was once the economic basis of Indian villages is on its decline.