Bhuvan-ultra is a famous real estate developer engaged mostly in housing projects. It has a very good track record of timely delivery of housing projects and enjoys a high level of trust among buyers. One of the ongoing projects of Bhuvan-ultra is a housing project with six residential towers. The construction has been in full swing for the last four years. Given the good record of the builder, all the flats have already been sold. Four out of six towers are complete and people have started living in these towers. Two other towers are near completion and it is expected that these would be ready in the next few months. Satish lives in a rented house and he daily crosses through this project on his commute to office. Satish always wanted to buy a flat in one of these towers. One day while reading the newspaper Satish came across a news article on the ongoing project of Bhuvan-ultra. Through the news article, he came to know that Bhuvan-ultra had permission to construct only four towers and it has illegally constructed two more towers in the project. The two illegal towers were standing on ground which was supposed to be a wetland. The entire conundrum points toward massive corruption and negligence by state development authorities. The matter went into the court and the court has ordered demolition of the two illegal towers. However, as the two illegal towers lie in close proximity with the other four legally constructed and inhabited towers, demolishing them is not only expensive but also a risky affair. Further, as all the six towers share a common basement, demolition of two towers can have implications for structural integrity of other four towers. Satish sits there thinking about the pain of the people who have invested their life's savings in the project and questioning whether he should ever invest in a residential property. He is also questioning himself whether demolition of a residential apartments in a country where lakhs of people are homeless, is justified or not. On the basis of above case study, answer the following: a) Identify various ethical dilemmas involved in this case study. b) What can be the other options to achieve justice in the given case, apart from demolition of the illegal towers? Evaluate each of these options and suggest the most suitable option.
Aaditya Pandey
This case presents challenges of corruption, crony capitalism and nepotism. Such things lead to social inequalities, thus belying the ideals of social justice and equality.
Stakeholders
1. Bhuvan - Ulka : Project developer, corrupt Real Estate agency 2. Satish - Objective on looker of news. 3. State Authorities. 4. Flat owners. 5. News and Media 6. Society at large. 7. Court
(a) Various ethical Dilemmas of this Case Study
1. Violation of Rule of law. 2. Encroaching upon wetlands thus envisonmental issues. 3. Against spirit of service for gross negligence by State Government Authorities. 4. Violation of Trust by Bhuvan-ulka 5. Profit seeking tendency at the cost of Safety and security 6. Lack of Probity and Integrity in Bhuvan ulka Case. 7. Objectivity of court orders vs Impact of demolition. 8. Environmental Challenges of demolition
(b) Various options available to ensure justice.
(1) use of the two towers for public purposes.
(2) Connect the towers as symbol of corruption instead of using negatively, message can be clear
(3) Illegal towers can be used for school and medical facilities by the Community
The best possible use is to convert the illegal towers in to school or medical facility. At the same time instituting an enquiry into any cross-benefits between developers and development authorities for corruption charges.