How far do you agree with the view that the National Green Tribunal (NGT) has met its objective of ensuring environmental justice in India?
Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025
NGT was established based on NGT act to ensure environmental protection, justice.
NGT met it objective of environmental Justice 1. Use of polluter pay for punishment to Industry causing harm eg Yamuna polluting Industry -> fine by NGT 2. Compensation to people harm due to environmental damage. eg Gas leak compensation 3. Suo-moto action for protection of environment based on precautionary approach. eg=> Taj Mahal SO₂ emission monitoring. 4. Reduce Judicial Delay in environmental cases by disposing cases in time limit 5. Use of principle of natural Justice to adopt principle of absolute liability in decision compensation (se suggest in mc Mehta case. 6. Policies input to government to strengthen law eg=> National Biodiversity Act amendment assitance to ensure Compliance with Nagoya Protocol
Limitation in meeting objective Legal 1. Forest Right Act, Indian Forest Act, wild life protection Act not under it jurisdiction - Can't ensure it compliance 2. Appointment delay create vacancy 3. Pending Cases and not adhesence to time-limit For finishing . 4. Misuse of Principle of Natural Justice For arbitary [?] without objective evidence ( Supreme court highlighted) 5. Capacity Constraint - Infrastructural Deficit - human resources
Way-Ahead 1. Expansion in NGT jurisdiction by amendment in NGT act to add all environmental act 2. Capacity building, Fund support, Streamline appointment
Supreme court recommendation of National Tribunal Commission will ensure NGT effective working