Topper Copies

Both India and the USA adhere to democratic principles but their electoral systems exhibit significant differences. What are the key differences in electoral practices between the two countries?

Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025

India is largest democracy" whereas USA is "oldest democracy". sharing democratic values. Both are having election in 2024

Same Democratic principles India and USA - written constitution - Rights to citizen - Freedom of speech - Independent judiciary - Universal adult franchise - Regular election - multi-party system - media freedom

Difference in electoral practices 1. National Election Conducting body - India has CEC (central Election Commission) A.324 conduct National/ state election - USA, on other hand, has various State bodies conducting all election, thus no national election body

2. Lobbying and Funding

| India | USA | |---|---| | Funding through cash allow and beyond 2000 maintain record | Funding: transparent and no limit of 2000, maintain record | | Lobbying not institutionalise, seen negative manner | Lobbying institutionalise with Industry open support and lobby further policy eg Oil Companies for Trump |

3. Presidential /Head Debate

| India | USA | |---|---| | No such provision | Traditional live streaming OR Debate |

4. Candidate election by party election

| India | USA | |---|---| | No, party tickets decide by party [?] election ↳ lack of [?] Consultation | Through presidential primary and election [?] Kamala ham[?] |

5. Limitation of freespeech

| India | USA | |---|---| | MCC, RPA 1951 | No such limitation |

Open

6. Endorsement by celebrities in USA, India no such 7. Mobilisation parameter

| India | USA | |---|---| | Caste, religion major factors | Policies such as pro-abortion secular issues dominate per constituency |

8. India has funding limitation USA no such 9. Use of EVM in India, USA uses Ballot papers

Thus, recommendation of Dinesh Goswami and Indrajit Gupta crucial for electoral reforms in India.