Topper Copies

Governors in India often overstep their constitutional role and fail to act effectively when needed. Comment.

Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025

Article 153 provided for Governor appointed by president as head of State government executive

Governor overstep their constitutional role 1. Interference in legislative process: by Delaying bill and reserving (A200) eg: TN governor reserving bill 2. Partisan nature in calling for party to formed government post election eg Maharashtra 2019 early morning oath 3. Misuse of Discretion (A 163) by not listening to council of ministers. (eg) kerala governor Vice cancellor Issue 4. Not Reading address in state assembly as per state government recommendation (Article 87) (eg) T.N. governor speech issue 5. Misuse of emergency provision! by acting as agent of center (eg) Report lacking substance highlighted by SC in Arunachal pradesh case 6. Initate Investigation against minister (eg) karnataka 7. Hold press conference and criticise state government (eg) west bengal 8. Removal of minister using A.163 pleasure doctrine (eg) TN governor

Fail to act when needed 1. when no majority in state, then calling of various alliances as per Punchi commission 2. violation of human Rights still no demand for investigation @ manipur 3. Crisis in state manipur; breakdown of Constitutional machinary still no emergency under (A 355) duty @ manipur governor 4. No effective reporting and regulation in 6th, 5th schedule area (Article 244) 5. Not reserving bill violation of constitutional principles @ narayana local reservation bill given assent - violation of Article 14

Reforms needed 1. Governor must adhere to constitutional morality in conduct (NCT vs GOI case) 2. Bound by state govt as SC highlighted 3. Report for A.356 must to speaking Document (Sarkaria Commission) 4. Fixed tenure as per law commission

Thus, recommendation of NCRWC, Sarkaria crucial for governor to act as bridge between Center and state