While the Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) plays a crucial role in combating corruption, its functioning is often criticized for being partisan and acting against the federal spirit. Discuss with the help of suitable examples.
Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025
CBI is non-constitutional body with power derived from Delhi police Special Establishment Act (DPSE). Recent withdraw of consent by state Brought it in news.
CBI role in Combating corruption 1. Assist CVC for investigation in Corruption matter as per it recommendation. 2. Deterrence to corruption due to its extensive power and scope of investigation 3. Reveal the links in corruption scam through rigorous research (eg) 2G scam 4. Policy suggestion to Union government to curb corruption. (eg) money laundering [?] Counter suggestion 5. Coordination with International agencies such as Interpol (eg) extradition of corrupt person 6. Investigate against Corrupt ion minister to ensure impartiality. (eg) Mahasasta former home minister case
CBI criticised for being partisan 1. Appointment of CBI head is executive discretion does Vulnerable to party favoritism (eg) No Committee like lokpal 2. Maximum cases against opposition leader make it seen as partisan agency (eg) SC remarked CBI as "caged party" 3. Cases dominated in state rules by opposition party, with limited action against same party at state by Center. (CPRS research) 4. Investigation: interference by politician has no procedurals check
Acting against federal spirit 1. Erode state power of police (Schedule 7) 2. misuse to topple government and cases of opposition minister - withdrawal of general consent by TN (Tamil Nadu) 3. No consultation with state in case of general will 4. No role of state in CBI functioning unlike GST council
Thus, Santhanam committee and B M Shah committe recommendation crucial to strengthen CBI.