Topper Copies

Executive accountability to the legislature through Parliamentary Committees has been the hallmark of the Indian political system. Comment.

Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025

A.75(3) provides for collective accountability of executive to legislature. It is assisted by Parliamentary committee (Congress in work → woodrow wilson remark)

Executive accountability through Parliamentary committees 1. Financial accountability: by Departmental Standing Committee (DPSC) by Budget scrutiny. 2. Delegated legislation accountability by Delegated legislation committee to ensure adherence to legal provision scrutiny of (eg) IT Act rules 3. Public Account committees help by CAG ensure scrutiny of various schemes (eg) PM Awas And CAG Audit lapse highlight by PAC 4. regulation of PSUs in effective manner by Public Sector Undertaking committee 5. Detail scrutiny of legislation to prevent misuse of future power. eg Telecom bill send to committee 6. Use of expert : Consultation to ensure executive schemes are implemented in robust manner 7. Public consultation : to ensure feedback and provide reports to parliament

Limitation of committee - 1 year tenure less time - limited technical & support - Recommendation not binding - only 25% Bill send (16th LS) - limited power to hold minister accountable - human Resource constraint - presence of minister → not effect scrutiny

Thus, US model of committee is right model for reference as "strong committee make strong parliament"