The Supreme Court of India has upheld unique asymmetry in India's federalism by intricately balancing centralized authority and regional autonomy. Discuss with the help of relevant case laws.
Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025
"India Federalism is Quasi-federal!" - K.C. wheare
India, as per D. R. Ambedkar, adopted Canadian model of federalism suited to Indian context with modification. SC re-iterated this through cases
Supreme upholding unique federalism form
1. Support to Union government power to create new states, change boundary (Article 3) eg A.370 case allow accepted conversion of J&K from state to UT. but said same case. 2. Emergency application on State allow if constitutional crisis (A.365) but suggest limitation. (eg) S. R. Bommai Case → emergency by governor only after floor test. 3. Protection to Regional Autonomy by misuse by governor interference. (eg) Rabam a Case governor power flow by cabinet and bound by it (A.163) 4. Federalism as part of BSD (Basic structure Doctrine. (eg) S.R. Bommai Case 5. GST Council decision not on State limitation taxation power (eg) Mohit minerals cases
Thus, Punchhi commission highlight over-centralisation lead to BP at Center and anemia at State recommendation of Sarkaria, NCRWC crucial for balance center State relation