The principle of impartiality may conflict with the need for compassion towards marginalized communities. Discuss in the context of civil services in India.
Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025
"First of all, I want all civil servant to be impartial" - Sardar Patel
Impartiality refer to not taking any sides and objective decision making.
Impartiality conflict with need of compassion -> Both foundational values
1. Impartiality may led to non-action in case of vulnerable exploitation. eg) Tribal land taken through moneylender trap 2. Data based decision make may led to denial of benefit to weaker section. eg) (lack of Document of Orphan son for school 3. No extra support to vulnerable will increase their marginalisation. eg) Slum clearing without alternate housing 4. Impartiality may increase their backward with respect to other. eg) Impartial appointment may led to less opportunities for backward caste
ways to Balance
1. Gandhian Talisman: with focus on last man in decision making. eg) rehabilitation support to Slum dwellers 2. Substantive Equality: with special provision for vulnerable. eg) IAS Gaurav Agarwal appoint LGBTQ 3. Constitutional morality: in case of conflict. eg) spirit of law - RTE - help orphan in document for school 4. Document any deviation in impartiality with reasons.
Thus, to achieve Kautilya "Yogakeshma" weakest member should be empowered