While accountability often necessitates documentation, an overemphasis on bureaucratic procedures and excessive paperwork can inadvertently silence the very voices that public policy intends to empower, particularly at the grassroots. Examine the above statement with suitable illustrations.
Aakash Om Trivedi, AIR 73, 2025
The Weberian Bureaucracy focus on complete adherence to rule, process and paper-work.
Accountability silence voices of people
1. Rules becomes end: lead to denial of benefit due to documentation gaps. eg) West Bengal MGNREGA Denial 2. Weberian Iron Cage: lead to compassion principles guidelines affect people. eg) Kanpur President convoy traffic jam lead to ambulance delay 3. lack of people feedback: inculcate into scheme. eg) Inclusion - Exclusion PDS 4. Deter Civil servant to innovate; to resolve - fear of CAG, CVC. eg) IAS HC gupta case 5. Relay in implementation: due to procedures deny rights. eg) Forest rights title delay (Xaxa Committee) 6. Reduce people participation: as top down approach to planning. eg) Gram Sabha guideline
Need for accountability
1. Rule of law ensures due to documentation 2. Trust of people as due process failed 3. Corruption is reduces as all paper 4. No waste of funds allocate
Way - Ahead
1. Use of E-governance to streamline 2. Code of ethics for discretion. eg) PM-GATISHAKTI 3. Bonafide mistake documentation no mistake 4. Streamline process (2nd ARC). Deregulation
Thus, PM modi motto "maximum governance, minimum government" crucial