True leadership lies in serving not ruling.
A R Rajah
One of the foremost flagship schemes that defined the governance of 21st century India was the Swachh Bharat scheme. This scheme's implementation across the country was spearheaded by Mr. Parameshwaran Iyer I.A.S., who served in his capacity as a Secretary of a Central ministry. One important aspect of the mission was the construction of a pit-system for collecting the human waste for composting. There was initial reluctance in the minds of the people, who were new to the concept of self-cleaning the pits. Mr. Iyer, showing the colours of his true personality and leadership, set an example for the people by jumping into the pit and cleaning the compost waste. This act of 'service' was photographed and published widely, promptly nudging the people to clean their compost pits.
The above anecdote showcases quite a few 'interesting things. Firstly, it shows how Mr. Iyer had a thirst for service and was fully focused on the effective implementation of a welfare scheme. Secondly, it also shows how his service mentality; fostered the true definition of leadership, influencing people towards a path of good character and well-being. He did not merely 'rule' and delegate work to his superdinates.
One can thus safely conclude that a true leader is all about service and not about ruling. Serving the needs of the people is what comes foremost on the duties of a leader. This primarily stems from the legitimacy of a leader's position. The Lincolnian dictum " of the people, for the people, by the people " shows the entrustment of power to the leader's hands, with public legitimacy. Thus, leaders owe their service to the people who choose them.
Now, one begins to wonder: is leadership always done on the principles of servitude? The honest answer would be in the negative. More often than not, people have suffered in the hands of apathetic leaders. The historical evidence of monarchy is a testimony to this fact. The legend of Spartacus talks in detail about the slave system of the Roman empire. The Roman monarchs acted merely as gate-keepers of power, pushing out servitude and people's welfare. The popular epic of 'Nero's fiddle', where the Roman monarch Nero played his fiddle while Rome burned, is an embodiment of a ruling mindset.
Leadership was also seen as a pertinent tool to wield power. Power was used to merely rule the people and also to continue staying in power. Machiavelli's book 'The Prince' talks about meaningful deceit of the people to stay in power. This ruse to legitimise leadership goes against the tenets of serving the people.
Take the case of Nazi Germany. Hitler and his propaganda chief Goebbels used their leadership to influence the people against a particular race. This form of leadership is all about setting up the narrative and mere ruling. There is no place for service in a Fascist regime.
After painting this dire picture of immoral leadership, one puts forward the next pertinent question: why should leadership be all about service ? Chanakya, the famous Indian political thinker writes in detail about this in his political magnum opus, 'Arthashastra'. Among the various enlisted functions of a king, the foremost is of taking care of his citizens as children. This encompasses the idea of serving the population as a true sign of a good leader.
Similar arguments can be seen in the 'Social contract' theory put forth by Hobbes and Locke. The legitimacy of a leader's power is based of on a contract with the citizens to serve them with equitable justice. Any deviation from this contract would lead to crumbling of leaderships. Marie Antoinette's proclamation of "Eat Cake" was truly a sign of a bad leader, not focused on service.
Mahatma Gandhi was a true embodiment of the word 'service'. He was projected as the leader of a diverse group: the harijans claimed him as theirs, the working class rallied around him and the elite gelled in with his barrister background. In short he was a collective 'Bapu' for all. This leadership role rose from his mindset of service, equitably reaching all the various groups of citizens.
True leadership is therefore all about gaining the trust of the people by serving them. Modern day democratic regimes are regularly punctuated with elections. These elections are merely exercises in trust, reinforced by how the politicians served the people. In essence, it mirrors the 'trusteeship principle' of Gandhi, by swapping wealth with leadership.
One now focuses on the various necessities of having a good leadership based on service. The foremost necessity would be the smooth operation of any organisation. In the corporate sector, the Chief Executive Officers and the board members form the leaders of the organisation. Instead of maintaining an alienating position, they should act to serve the interests of the employees. Ratan Tata, founder of the Tata group of companies, is worth mention here. His CSR activities were exercises in proper ethical service, thus making him a good leader.
Another necessity would be in the sector of public governance. Civil servants should follow the foot steps of officers like Mr. Iyer and become Karmayogis in serving the public and dishing out citizen centric governance.
There are however quite a few challenges in achieving this service mindset. The foremost is the prevalent culture of corruption that derails even the most honest officers. Recent case of malpractice in the Civil services examination and the subsequent dismissal of officer Pooja Khedkar showcases how service is the last thing on their minds.
Similar examples of unfair termination of employees during the COVID Pandemic showed the apathy of corporate leadership. This again highlights a profit centric leadership, rather than a service minded one.
A number of steps should be taken in this regard. Primarily, the dictum of "with great power comes great responsibility" popularised in movies, should be put to practicality. Values of openness and transparency should essentialy dictate leadership, fostering servitude. The recent example of having an open seating plan in Kartavya Bhawan, the new secretariat building, is a step in this direction.
Similarly, the nation as such should move towards becoming a leader of service. India has rose to become the leader of global south. This leadership came with the various services provided to other countries, like 'Vaccine Maitri' programme. Thus, even countries can become true global leaders by inculcating values of service.
To summarise, one takes back a simple formula: serve the people around you in your fullest capacity, and raise to become leaders of tomorrow. For, what else can be more important in life than serving people who need them? Gandhi fantastically brings out the essence in his quote,
"Lose yourself in the service of others"