Topper Copies

Explain various forms of exchange systems in simple societies with the help of appropriate examples

Tanuj Pathak, AIR 72, 2023

Various forms of Exchange →

Karl Polanyi in his book " The Great transformation 1944 " gave three forms of exchange in simple societies → reciprocity → redistribution → Market exchange

1. RECIPROCITY → It means exchange of goods and services without the use of Money.

Sahlins gave three types of Reciprocity → Generalised → Balanced → Negative

- Generalised Reciprocity → It means exchange of goods & services without any expectation of return. - Eg) Parents provide food, clothes, education to their children without any expectation of return. - Eg) Dr. Lorna Marshall recorded how meat is distributed after a hunt in ! KUNG society. The hunters distribute the meat amongst kinsmen and other people without anything in return. - Balance reciprocity -> Exchange of Goods and services with expectation of return either immediately or within a stipulated time period. - (Eg) Bantu <——> !Kung (Hunters): ( Spears / Tobacco ) <> Hides / ostrich eggs - (Eg) KULA RING by Malinowski ——> Exchange of Non-economic items. Reason for exchange is better relations between the Kula partners. Mwali is given and Soulava is received or Soulava is given and Mwali is recieved. - Negative reciprocity -> In this exchange both try to benefit from the transaction, often at the expense of other. - (Eg) In NAVAJO tribe of America deceit is allowed during trade with foreigners. 2. REDISTRIBUTION → Mostly found in societies with a political hierarchy. In this goods and services are accumulated at a single place and they they are distributed back to the people. - POTLATCH → explained by Franz Boas in his Kwakiutl text 1895. In potlatch, the chief organise a feast, in which all the guest are given same present/gifts from the chief. In Kwakiutl it can be → blankets, canoes, copper, fish oil. It also involves destruction of wealth to show generosity, and solidarity with kin. - In Parang Poja Tribe → People provide labour to NAIK (chief) during hunting and he redistributes the hunt to the people. 3. MARKET EXCHANGE →

Tribal societies have peripheral market i.e. the objective of Market is more social then economical.

- Economic functions of Market → Exchange of goods / buying-selling with the help of CASH. → however factor of production are not brought into the market. Eg Masai never sell their cattle - - Non economic functions of Market → Political { Market help in controlling people, thus possessing power }. → Marriage } suitable matches are found in Markets. Eg In BHILS.

Due to Globalization & Modernization, CASH Economy has penetrated into the tribal societies, However internal transaction still takes place via reciprocity & redistribution